Two facts shape every journey you will make here. There is exactly one road onto Sanibel and you pay to use it. And once you are on the island, the bicycle is genuinely faster, cheaper and more pleasant than the car for most of what you will want to do.
The Sanibel Causeway carries the only road link, running from Punta Rassa on the mainland across San Carlos Bay to the eastern end of the island. It opened in 1963 and was replaced in 2007 with the higher flyover span you cross today. Hurricane Ian severed it on 28 September 2022 and cut the islands off entirely; emergency repairs restored traffic within weeks and permanent reconstruction was completed in 2024. The crossing today is unremarkable, which after what happened is the point.
The toll is charged in one direction only, on the way onto the island. Leaving is free. Expect something in the region of $6 with a SunPass or compatible transponder and around $9 if it is billed to your licence plate, with surcharges for additional axles. Rates get reviewed, so confirm the current figure rather than budgeting from an old article. If you are staying a week and going back and forth to the mainland, that is a real line in the budget rather than a rounding error.
Once you are across, the island does not behave like the rest of Florida. There are two through roads. Periwinkle Way runs along the eastern half; Sanibel-Captiva Road carries the island north-west to the Blind Pass Bridge and on to Captiva. There are no traffic signals. Junctions are four-way stops, the speed limits are low and enforced, and traffic simply moves more slowly than you expect.
Alongside those roads runs the thing that actually defines transport here: more than 26 miles of shared-use path, physically separated from the traffic rather than painted onto the shoulder, running from Lighthouse Beach Park at the eastern point to the Blind Pass Bridge in the west. It connects the beach parks, the refuge entrance, the shell museum, the shops and most residential areas. It is the reason a great many visitors here park the car on Sunday and do not move it again until Friday, and it is also the answer to the island's single largest recurring cost, which is beach parking.
What follows covers the causeway in detail, the bike path and its rules, driving and parking honestly, getting here from the airport, and what the options are if cycling is not realistic for you.