There is one museum in the United States given over entirely to shells and molluscs, and it is on Sanibel, which makes complete sense once you understand why the island collects shells in the first place: an exceptionally broad continental shelf off south-west Florida, the local set of currents, and an island that runs east to west instead of north to south and therefore sits broadside to what the Gulf is carrying.
It is two museums under one roof. The Great Hall of Shells is the original: an octagonal gallery with thirty-foot ceilings, drawing on a scientific collection that now runs to nearly 600,000 specimens. The Living Gallery of Aquariums is the newer half, with roughly sixty species of molluscs and other marine animals in tanks that range from Pacific coral reef to south-west Florida red mangrove, plus two large touch pools. The institution took accreditation from the Association of Zoos and Aquariums in 2022 and its full name now carries "& Aquarium" for good reason.
The founding story is unusually specific. A 1984 bequest from a local collector, Charlene McMurphy, seeded the idea. The malacologist R. Tucker Abbott came on board as adviser and then founding director, and recruited his friend Raymond Burr — the actor, and a serious shell collector — to raise the profile and the money. In 1989 three brothers, Francis, Samuel and John Bailey, deeded eight acres on Sanibel-Captiva Road in memory of their parents, Frank P. Bailey and Annie Mead Matthews, whose names the museum carries. It opened in 1995.
Hurricane Ian did serious damage in 2022, and the rebuild took three years. The Great Hall reopened in two phases, in May and October 2025, and the museum treats the second of those as the end of its reconstruction.