Historic site
Last updated
A hundred acres, one inn, no cars and no bridge — an island lunch on top of a shell mound the Calusa spent centuries building.
UnsplashPhoto: UnsplashUnsplash License
Cabbage Key is a hundred acres of tropical vegetation in Pine Island Sound with a restaurant on it, and the only way to reach the restaurant is to cross open water. Boaters find it by channel marker 60. Everyone else arrives on a scheduled passenger boat from Captiva or Pine Island, which is roughly an hour and a quarter's drive plus a boat ride from the Sanibel Causeway. That effort is the entire character of the place. Nobody ends up at Cabbage Key by accident.
The island itself is older than anything on it. The buildings stand on a shell mound the island gives as thirty-eight feet high, raised over centuries by the Calusa, the people who ran this coast from a base of fish, shell and water long before anyone arrived to name things. That mound is why there is high, dry ground here at all in a sound where most islands are mangrove at sea level.
On top of it sits an inn dating from the 1930s, later converted to a restaurant with rooms and cottages around it. What people talk about afterwards is the walls. Dollar bills, signed and taped across every surface of the bar and dining room, layered thick enough that the room reads as green. The tradition is said to have begun with a fisherman leaving money against a future drink; whatever its origin, a substantial quantity falls down each year and is collected for charity.
The island claims to be the birthplace of a very famous song about a cheeseburger. So do several other establishments on this coast, none of them with a definitive answer, and the argument is conducted with more enjoyment than rigour. Order one anyway.
There are no cars. Paths are unpaved and a short trail loops the interior. Most visitors get two or three hours ashore, which is exactly right.
No bridge, no road, no exceptions. Boaters navigate to channel marker 60 in Pine Island Sound.
From Sanibel, the usual route is to drive the length of the island and Captiva to the bay-side docks, about an hour from the causeway in season, and take a scheduled passenger boat from there. Services also sail from Bokeelia and Pineland on Pine Island, which is a longer drive and a shorter crossing.
Charter captains based on Sanibel, Captiva and Pine Island will run the trip directly and wait, which suits a group and allows a shelling stop on the return.
Visiting boats can take dockage at the island. Telephone ahead about a slip, especially around lunchtime between January and April.
Everything is weather-dependent, and in summer the afternoon storm pattern can cut a trip short with little warning.
The scheduled boat. Passenger services sail from Captiva's bay-side docks, usually calling at Cabbage Key as a lunch stop and sometimes combining it with Cayo Costa or Useppa. The drive from the Sanibel Causeway to the Captiva docks is around an hour in season, so allow for it. Book ahead; these boats fill from January to April.
From Pine Island. Operators also run from Bokeelia and Pineland on the mainland side, which is a longer drive from Sanibel but a shorter crossing.
Your own boat. Dockage is available for visitors, and the island is a standard stop on the Intracoastal. Call ahead about a slip rather than arriving and hoping, particularly at lunchtime in season.
Charter. A captain will run you out and wait. For a group this is often the most flexible option and lets you fold in a shelling stop on the way back.
Whichever you choose, the return crossing is not negotiable and the last boat is the last boat. Weather cancels sailings, and afternoon storms in summer do so at short notice.
The dining room and bar occupy the old house, screened porches and all, with the sound visible through the trees. Every interior surface carries dollar bills, signed, dated and taped in overlapping layers by visitors going back decades. People hunt for their own from previous trips and occasionally find them.
Estimates of how much money is on the walls at any moment run into the tens of thousands of dollars. A steady percentage falls off as the tape ages, and the island collects and donates it rather than pocketing it.
A water tower stands on the mound, and from it the view runs out across Pine Island Sound to the barrier islands. Access arrangements vary and it is not always open, so treat it as a bonus rather than a plan.
The food is unfussy American island fare and the cheeseburger is the thing people order, for reasons of legend rather than gastronomy. Service is paced to a room full of people who arrived by boat and are in no hurry.
Rooms and cottages are available for overnight stays, which is a genuinely different proposition: once the day boats leave, there are a couple of dozen people on a hundred-acre island with no cars and no streetlights.
Most visitors never leave the porch, which is a shame, because the island is more interesting than the lunch.
A short nature trail loops away from the buildings through gumbo limbo, cabbage palm and sea grape, with interpretive markers in places. It takes twenty minutes at a stroll and is the only way to appreciate how much height the shell mound actually gives you.
The shoreline is mangrove rather than beach, so this is not a swimming stop. The undeveloped beaches nearby on the outer islands are, and boat operators often pair the two.
Gopher tortoises live on the higher ground. Ospreys nest on the channel markers. Dolphins work the sound and are commonly seen on the crossing in both directions, which is why several operators sell the trip as a wildlife cruise with lunch attached rather than the other way round.
Insects are present in the interior at dawn and dusk. In the middle of the day, when the boats come, they are not much of an issue.
Take your rubbish back with you. Everything that arrives on this island leaves by boat, including what you brought.
Time ashore. Scheduled trips typically give you two to three hours. That is enough for lunch, the trail and a wander. It is not enough to swim, shell properly and eat, so choose.
Season. January to April is busy and the boats sell out. Late spring and autumn are quieter and the crossings are often smoother. Summer brings heat, humidity and afternoon storms that can shorten or cancel a sailing.
Cost shape. The boat fare is the significant expense; lunch is ordinary restaurant money. Budget the trip as a boat excursion with a meal rather than as a meal with transport.
Who it suits. Anyone who likes the idea of an island you cannot drive to, boaters, and families with children old enough to enjoy an hour on the water each way. Less suitable for anyone prone to seasickness on a choppy crossing, or for a group that wants a beach day.
What is not there. No shops beyond a small selection at the inn, no cash machine, no pharmacy and limited mobile signal. Bring what you need.
Hours and prices change with the season and the operator. Confirm both before you travel.
Operators run these trips past Cabbage Key, or stop there as part of a longer route. We list what the booking data supports — not everything that mentions the name.
These go through Viator and we take a commission. Same price to you, and no bearing on what we chose to put here.
Weather Dependent - Moderate
Skip the hassle of carrying bulky beach gear and arrive to two chairs and an umbrella waiting on a groomed beach at the Lani Kai Resort…
Full day
Prices checked
Involves Animals
Come join us for a once in a lifetime experience that is great for all skill levels. There are only a few places on earth to see the West…
2 hours
Prices checked
Short term availability
This eco kayak tour offers an unmatched blend of adventure, wildlife, and top-tier equipment. Unlike standard tours with Perception Tribe…
2 hours
Prices checked
Short term availability
During these trips, Guests will have the option to fish the back bays or offshore. In the bays, guests can target Snook, Redfish, Trout…
4 hours
Prices checked
Involves Animals
Captain Lauren with SWFL Party Pontoon is a marine biologist with years on the water in the area. Tours are catered to the group on board…
4 hours
Prices checked
Bus Tours
Experience the road to Hana in ultimate comfort in a private luxury SUV for groups of up to 5 or a transit van for groups of up to 12. We…
Full day
Prices checked
Straight-line distances, so allow more on the road — the island is long and has one main parkway.
Park
Nine miles of state-park beach with no bridge, where the tide line rebuilds itself between boats instead of being picked over by nine.
4–8 hoursFlorida state park entry fee, usually collected on arrival; the boat fare is a separate and much larger cost.1.9 mi away
Neighbourhood
A different island across a 200-foot pass: one road, one village, no dogs on the sand and parking that costs several times Sanibel's.
3–8 hoursNo charge to visit. Parking is the real cost, and it varies by which authority runs the lot.9.5 mi away
Nature preserve
The mangrove island that shelters Captiva's back side — somewhere you paddle around rather than somewhere you step ashore.
1.5–4 hoursFree to paddle. Kayak hire and guided trips are the cost.9.8 mi away
Beach
Captiva's north-end public beach, where the parking pays for the sand you are standing on and an all-day space costs more than lunch.
1.5–5 hoursNo admission charge. Parking is paid by the hour or by the day and is the most expensive on either island.8.9 mi away
Where this place fits into a day, and the pages that plan one.
Guide hub
Sanibel lies east to west. Nearly every other barrier island on Florida's Gulf coast lies north to south, running parallel with the mainland, and…
Guide hub
Sanibel is a long, thin island with essentially two through roads, so it is easier to understand as a line than as a list. Periwinkle Way runs from…
Guide hub
Most destinations have wildlife somewhere near the edges. Sanibel organised itself around it. When the causeway opened in 1963 and Lee County's plan…
Who it suits
Sanibel is a quiet island with an early bedtime, and that is either exactly what you want from a week together or the wrong choice entirely. There…
Things to do
The reason to get on a boat here is not the view from the deck. It is that a short run north puts you on islands that have no bridge, no road and no…
Guide
Cross the pass and the island turns ninety degrees. Captiva runs north to south and faces west, which is why the sunset is there and not here.
8 min readHarriet Lowell
By boat only. Most visitors drive the length of Sanibel and Captiva to the bay-side docks, about an hour from the causeway in season, and take a scheduled passenger service that calls at Cabbage Key for lunch. Operators also sail from Bokeelia and Pineland on Pine Island. Private boats navigate to channel marker 60 and take dockage at the island. Book ahead between January and April.
A tradition going back decades. Visitors sign a dollar bill and tape it to the wall or ceiling of the bar and dining room, and the layers are now thick enough that the rooms read as green. The story usually told is that a fisherman left a bill against a future drink. Bills fall down steadily as the tape ages, and what comes off is collected and given to charity rather than kept by the island.
It claims to be, and so do several other places on this coast, and there is no settled answer. The island is comfortable with the ambiguity and the argument is part of the fun. What is true is that the cheeseburger is what nearly everyone orders, and that arriving by boat for lunch on a hundred-acre island with no cars is a better story than the burger itself.
Yes. The inn has rooms and there are rental cottages on the island, which makes for a genuinely unusual night: once the day boats leave, a couple of dozen people share a hundred acres with no cars, no streetlights and no through traffic. There is no shop to speak of, no cash machine and limited mobile signal, so arrive with what you need. Check current availability and rates directly with the island.
Scheduled trips typically allow two to three hours ashore, which covers lunch, the short interior nature trail and a look at the view from the mound. That is not enough time to also swim or shell properly, so plan the day as an island lunch with a boat ride rather than a beach outing. Charters can give you longer, and boaters can obviously stay as long as they like.